America may never recover from the trauma of watching drunk coeds making monkey noises on a Ring camera this month. White girls at Ole Miss were responsible for this horrific atrocity that permanently scarred the black apartment dwellers.
The Ole Miss monkey noise scandal is one of the most ridiculous cancel culture stories of my lifetime. We’re supposed to believe this innocuous event is the equivalent of a lynching. Network TV covered this extremely unimportant incident in the somberest of tones and interviewed the “victims” as if they had narrowly escaped ISIS.
The case indicates something like woke is re-emerging. This would not have been a national news story when Trump was inaugurated last year. It follows the hysteria over the Cornell 7 and other stories that show the country once again engaging in left-wing outrage and cancel culture.
Stories like this are made possible by the panopticon citizens have created on their own. There’s a lot of public concern over Flock cameras and other forms of state surveillance. What’s less discussed is how Americans spy on each other every day. One argument, one silly drunk moment, or one wrong text can be shared to the entire world without your permission and ruin your life. The public seems perfectly fine with this voluntaristic nightmare. As long as the surveillance is done by a private individual rather than the government, it causes no great concern.
The voluntaristic panopticon makes us less free and more beholden to the fickle whims of the mob. You can blame your fellow citizens for making that possible.
Think about the Ole Miss story, minus the camera footage. Imagine anyone caring about drunk coeds making monkey sounds at an apartment complex filled with college students. No one would care except those who were woken up by the noise. But in 2026 America, it’s one of the biggest news stories in the country. The video was tailor-made for social media and guaranteed to garner a reaction. Three attractive young white women doing a “racism” is bound to anger people. They fit the role we imagine of how racism plays out. Privileged and crude white people terrorizing poor minorities minding their own business.
It was the same with Karen controversies. Proper society would like to believe that black men have more to fear from middle-aged white women calling the police than the women have to fear from the black men. When a random black person pulled out their smartphone on a Karen telling them to turn down their music or asking what they’re doing in their apartment building, it supported a popular delusion. Both the media and ordinary people could point the finger at such a case as proof of the horrible racism that blacks apparently face every day. And it’s all made possible by the voluntaristic panopticon.
One of the worst examples of this trend occurred in 2020. A black guy falsely claimed a white woman, wearing a mask in her car, did something racist and he was going to make her famous. The woman, realizing her life would be over because of the false accusation, cried in terror and pleaded that her husband was black. The clip still went viral. There is no “innocent until proven guilty” standard when it comes to social media shaming.
While the fervor for cancel culture has receded a bit over the years, we are witnessing more frivolous events become national stories. Besides the Ole Miss case, there is now a flood of people getting shamed for what they do on airplanes. Sending a private text with naughty words or refusing to move seats for a minority can make you the latest target of internet hate. One man was arrested for sending offensive jokes to friends while flying. When every American feels obligated to spy on strangers, this is what we get.
The voluntaristic panopticon fits in with the character of this country, albeit a mutated and impersonal form of it.
Alexis de Tocqueville and many other commentators remarked on the voluntaristic aspect of American society. “Americans of all ages, all stations of life, and all types of disposition are forever forming associations,” the Frenchman wrote in Democracy in America. We would organize ourselves in churches and other associations without the encouragement of the government. These groups would maintain unwritten rules and norms in communities throughout the land. That associational character has diminished over the years. Many Americans belong to nothing today and civil associations are in steep decline. Atomization rather than associationalism characterizes the country today.
However, our voluntarism still emerges in other ways, especially with private surveillance and cancel culture. We don’t like the government cracking down on speech, but we still feel the need to police comments and acts we deem immoral. The offending “immorality” is a lot different from what 19th century Americans would’ve considered wrong, but it still evokes the same fervor. Citizens target racism, sexism, xenophobia, and other forms of political incorrectness with their smartphones. We no longer have structures within communities to correct these offenses, so the internet serves as the replacement. Now millions of strangers let the offending party know they did a racism through doxing, harassment, and even death threats.
This is also very different from the social policing of the past. It would be your friends, neighbors, and fellow congregants telling you you did wrong. Now it’s just strangers on the street and randos on the internet deeming you a racist. It’s an impersonal shaping that fits our hyperatomized society.
It’s also rather democratic. In the past, we could blame the media for highlighting stories they should have ignored or done a better job of investigating, such as the Duke Lacrosse case. The old media environment was a much more top-down affair. That’s not as true today thanks to social media. These panopticon tales first get big through people willfully choosing to repost and discuss them on the platforms before traditional media picks them up. The people of the internet make it an important story, not some shadowy elite. Network TV would’ve never mentioned the Ole Miss monkey noise scandal if it weren’t one of the biggest trending topics on social media. The mob chooses on its own to get mad about these affronts. The media now just follows the crowd.
Excessive private surveillance comes at a time when the public is turning strongly against government surveillance. Flock bans were a hit with voters in the midterms, with both Democrats and Republicans railing against the license plate readers. Based on the outrage, you would think Flock cameras are the first sign of any surveillance in the country. When critics are told about all the other ways you’re spied on in public, they insist they can opt out of that–unlike with Flock. But you actually can’t opt out of your neighbor recording you on their Ring camera or your argument in the grocery store going viral on the internet. In fact, the individual has less control over this than state surveillance. You can at least petition to limit where your town puts these cameras or get them taken down. You can also prove your innocence in court. You have no say over where your fellow citizens film you when you step out of your house. And there’s no way to prove your innocence once you’re declared guilty by the mob. The Ole Miss coeds made the monkey noises in front of other apartments, but that doesn’t matter. They’re forever branded as racists for doing it in front of the one apartment occupied by blacks.
We seem fine with this. As long as it’s not the big bad government behind it, Americans are fine with their every move being watched.
It’s a product of us becoming an atomized, low-trust society. It’s more common to view everyone with suspicion. You have no idea who the person parking next to you is or who’s getting too close to you in the produce aisle. Nextdoor and Facebook community pages are filled with locals freaking out about the new mailman and other benign activities in their neighborhood. There’s nothing more terrifying for many Americans than someone knocking at their door.
This is an understandable response when no one knows anyone around them. And you don’t want to be the idiot who doesn’t catch the porch pirate stealing your packages. There’s a reason more and more people have Ring cameras.
But the ubiquity of this tech turns the public sphere into a panopticon run by strangers who owe no obligation to you. You’re literally one wrong noise or comment away from an unseen camera sharing it with the whole world.
That’s the nature of the voluntaristic panopticon.
Order Scott Greer’s new book, “Whitepill: The Online Right and the Making of Trump’s America,” from this link.


I think the worst example was the case where a White woman was harassed by blk twitter for trying to take her bike back from some black young adults trying to steal it. Does anyone remember that? I think it was 2021
Christian Cooper, the black man who filmed "karen in the park" after vaguely threatening her dog, got his own short-lived nature tv show as a reward from the panopticon